thozhanias@gmail.com

 

Lokpal and Lokayukta – part 1

1. Background and GenesisOmbudsman Concept: Originated in Sweden, 1809, to investigate citizens’ complaints against maladministration.
India:

  • 1960s: Law Minister Ashok Kumar Sen proposed a constitutional Ombudsman.
  • 1963: Dr. L.M. Singhvi coined Lokpal (central) and Lokayukta (state).
  • 1966: 1st Administrative Reforms Commission (ARC) recommended separate authorities at central and state levels.
  • 1968: Lokpal Bill passed in Lok Sabha but lapsed.
  • 2002 & 2005: NCRWC and 2nd ARC recommended Lokpal/Lokayukta again.
  • 2011: Anna Hazare’s India Against Corruption movement demanded a strong Lokpal.
  • 2013: Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act passed, establishing these bodies legally.

2. Lokpal – Central Ombudsman
Legal Basis

Statutory body under the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013.
Investigates corruption complaints against central government officials.
Composition
Chairperson + up to 8 Members
Judicial Members: ≥50% must be judges or former judges.
Social Representation: 50% must belong to SC/ST, OBC, minorities, or women.
Selection Committee
Prime Minister (Chairperson)
Speaker of Lok Sabha
Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha (or leader of largest opposition party if no LoP)
Chief Justice of India (or a nominated Judge)
One eminent jurist appointed by President
Jurisdiction
Central Ministers, MPs, and Group A-D government employees.
Prime Minister: Special procedure applies.
Extraterritorial: Indian citizens abroad under FCRA (> Rs 10 lakh/year).
Powers
Investigation & Inquiry: Can order investigation against officials.
Superintendence: Can direct CBI and oversee CVC in corruption cases.
Prosecution: Recommend prosecution before Special Courts.
Preventive Measures: Monitor asset declarations, recommend vigilance measures.

3. Lokayukta – State Ombudsman

  • State-level equivalent of Lokpal.
  • Established via state legislation within 365 days of central Act.
  • Jurisdiction over state ministers, MLAs, and state government employees.
  • Structure & powers vary by state, usually include judicial and non-judicial members.

4. Key Features of Lokpal & Lokayukta Act, 2013

Feature Description
Composition Chairperson + max 8 members; 50% judicial, 50% from SC/ST/OBC/minorities/women
Jurisdiction PM, Ministers, MPs, Group A-D employees, FCRA cases
Superintendence Can direct CBI for investigations; oversee CVC
State Lokayukta Must be established via state legislation
Eligibility Chairperson/member ≥45 years; cannot be MPs/MLAs; judicial background for half members

5. Role as Ombudsman

  • Investigates corruption complaints against ministers, MPs, and officials.
  • Acts as a check on maladministration and abuse of power.
  • Ensures accountability and transparency in public administration.

6. Limitations / Challenges

  • Government Influence: Appointment process may affect independence.
  • Incomplete Implementation: Many states have not set up Lokayukta.
  • Complaint Restrictions: Anonymous complaints not allowed; 7-year limitation.
  • Investigative Restrictions: Cannot initiate suo moto investigations.
  • Resource Constraints: Limited manpower and funding slow proceedings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *